Warm wood breakfast nook with an upholstered bench and walnut table beside a window overlooking snow-dusted pines in Evergreen.

Gas or Propane? What It Takes to Heat an Evergreen Home This Winter

Two Evergreen listings can share a price, a square footage and a ridgeline view and still be heated in very different ways. One has an Xcel gas meter on the side of the house. The other has a propane tank partway down the driveway. Evergreen is inside Xcel Energy's natural gas territory, and AmeriGas also keeps an office on Bryant Drive, so both setups are common here. The fuel line on a listing sheet tells you how a house is heated. This winter it also says something about what the house costs to run and what it needs from its owner once the snow comes.

Xcel's Public Service Company of Colorado gas tariff lists Evergreen and Bergen Park as gas service localities, along with Kittredge and Aspen Park. That list names towns. It doesn't map streets. Ponderosa Heating, an Evergreen HVAC contractor, says both fuels are common across town and that each property's fuel should be checked rather than guessed from its address.

Propane started this winter above where last winter peaked

The U.S. Energy Information Administration put Colorado's average residential propane price at $2.445 a gallon for the week of November 9, 2026, before taxes. EIA's weekly series opened last heating season at $2.078 a gallon in the week of October 6, 2025, and peaked at $2.304 in the week of March 23, 2026. Averaged across all 26 weeks from October 2025 through March 2026, it came to about $2.22. That puts this November's price above last winter's most expensive week and about 18% above where the 2025-26 season began.

Those are statewide averages, not a quote from a particular Evergreen supplier for a particular tank. They do show the direction. A household that budgeted last winter's propane at around $2.22 a gallon is starting this one well above that.

Gas bills rose by a smaller share

Natural gas customers also pay more this winter, though by a smaller share. Xcel says the Colorado gas rate case approved in September raised the average residential bill by about 8.6%, or $5.15 a month, starting October 6, 2026. The Denver Post reported the same 8.6% increase and put the monthly figure at $5.16. EIA's average Colorado residential gas price for August 2026 was $17.94 per thousand cubic feet, 3% above the $17.41 recorded in August 2025. In its winter fuels outlook, released November 10, 2026, EIA projects households in the West will spend about 7% more on natural gas heat this winter. That forecast covers the whole region, not Evergreen in particular.

Gallons of propane and cubic feet of gas are different units, so these percentages don't reduce to a single bill comparison. Over the past year, though, the statewide propane price rose by roughly twice the share of Xcel's average residential gas bill increase. For a buyer weighing two similar houses, last winter's heating bills on a propane home are a weaker guide to this winter's than they are on a gas home.

A propane tank comes with a delivery schedule

Price is one part of the difference. The other part is that propane arrives by truck, so the house depends on a delivery in a way a gas meter never does.

The AmeriGas Evergreen office at 30455 Bryant Drive handles residential delivery and tank installation. Reach it at (303) 674-3321, because it doesn't serve walk-in customers. AmeriGas runs three delivery arrangements: automatic, fixed-cycle and will-call. It tells will-call customers to order when the tank reaches 30% and quotes typical delivery at 7 to 10 days, with faster delivery sometimes available for an extra fee. In a cold January, ten days is a lot of furnace run time, so ask which delivery plan the seller has been using.

The driveway matters too. AmeriGas's terms and conditions, effective October 1, 2026, require a path to the tank that is clear of snow, ice and debris. The driveway also has to hold a loaded delivery truck. The terms note that extreme weather and road conditions can delay delivery. On a foothills lot with a long, steep or shaded drive, getting the truck to the tank in winter is part of owning the house.

Another regional supplier, Independent Propane Company, lists Evergreen and Pine among the Central Front Range mountain communities it serves. It leases tanks, does residential delivery and monitors tank levels to help prevent run-outs. For a second-home owner who isn't in Evergreen every week, a monitored tank means the supplier knows the level even when nobody is there to read the gauge.

Who owns the tank

Tank ownership is easy to miss when comparing two propane houses. AmeriGas's terms allow customers to own or lease their tanks. A leased tank belongs to the supplier, so a buyer who would rather use a different company may have to sort out the tank as well as the fuel. AmeriGas describes fixed-price plans as something it may offer through promotions or in certain areas. With prices starting the season where they are, ask the supplier whether a fixed price is available on the Evergreen route before the coldest months.

None of this makes a propane house a weaker choice. A tank with a clear drive and a reliable delivery plan heats a home as well as a gas line does. It does add questions to the list, and this year the price behind those questions has moved more.

Questions that come up when comparing two homes

How do I confirm which fuel a house uses?

Ask the seller which utility or propane company serves the house, then look on the property for a gas meter or a tank. Both fuels are common across Evergreen, so confirm each house on its own rather than assuming from the neighborhood.

What should I ask a seller about a propane tank?

Ask who owns the tank, which company delivers, whether the house is on automatic, fixed-cycle or will-call delivery, and what the last twelve months of deliveries cost. That record shows how the house actually uses fuel far better than a statewide average price can.

Can a propane house switch to natural gas?

Only where a gas main is close enough to reach, and that's a question for Xcel about the specific address. The equipment inside the house has to change too. A furnace set up for natural gas and one set up for propane need different orifices and manifold pressure, an Evergreen furnace may need an altitude adjustment as well, and contractors quote that work individually.

The prices here are general information as of mid-November 2026, not financial advice. Confirm current costs for any specific property with the utility, the propane supplier and a licensed heating contractor.

If you're comparing Evergreen homes this winter, put the fuel question on the list early. Closing Colorado and Mary Rosinski can help you ask each seller the right questions about tanks, delivery and driveways, so the homes on your shortlist are compared on what they take to run as well as on price. Start your mountain move with that side-by-side conversation.

Work with Mary

Passion. Energy. Drive. That is how we move. That is how we will move you. As Certified Mountain Area Specialists, we can protect you when you are selling or buying mountain property.

Follow Me on Instagram